top of page

Employ Someone or Outsource the Call: What the New Employment Rights Act Actually Changes For You

Michael Bolt
Nov 13
5 min read
Employ Someone or Outsource the Call: What the New Employment Rights Act Actually Changes For You

Hiring someone feels like the safe option. You know what you are getting, they are on your payroll, and if the phone needs answering, they answer it. Except the Employment Rights Act 2025 has just made that calculation a good deal more complicated for anyone running a small business with a lean team, and the numbers behind a straightforward front-of-house hire have shifted enough that it is worth putting them side by side with the alternative before you sign an offer letter.

 

So here is what this article does: it puts direct employment and outsourced call handling against the same set of criteria, uses real figures, and says plainly which option suits whom.

 

What a £30,000 salary actually costs you

 

The headline salary is the number that goes in the job advert. It is not the number that leaves your bank account.

 

Employer National Insurance sits at 15%. The Secondary Threshold, the point at which you start paying it, dropped to £5,000 per year from April 2025. So on a £30,000 salary, you are paying 15% on £25,000 of earnings above that threshold. That is £3,750 in employer NIC alone. Add the salary, and you are at £33,750 before a single day has been worked.

 

Now add pension contributions. Auto-enrolment minimum is 3% employer contribution on qualifying earnings, which on £30,000 runs to roughly £900 per year. You are now at £34,650.

 

The Employment Allowance has increased to £10,500, and the £100,000 eligibility cap has been removed, which helps. If this is your only employee and your NIC bill is below £10,500, you may not pay employer NIC at all in the current year. But if you have two or three people already on the payroll, that allowance is already spoken for, and the full £3,750 lands.

 

Then there is everything that does not appear in a salary comparison at all. Recruitment costs. Training time. The weeks before someone is genuinely useful. Holiday cover. And from 6 April 2026, Statutory Sick Pay is a day-one right, with no waiting period and no minimum earnings threshold. The first day an employee calls in sick, you are paying. On a role that is fundamentally about being present and available, that matters rather a lot.

 

The liability that arrives after six months

 

The unfair dismissal qualifying period currently sits at two years. From 1 January 2027, it drops to six months.

 

That is not a distant change. If you hire someone in November 2026, they reach the six-month mark in May 2027. By that point, if the role is not working, the exit is not a quiet conversation and a notice period. It is a process, documented, with full unfair dismissal protections in play from that point forward.

 

For a front-of-house or reception role, where a hire that looks fine on paper can turn out to be wrong for the business in ways that are genuinely hard to pin down, this is a meaningful shift. The recruitment round needs to be right first time, because the cost of getting it wrong has gone up.

 

None of which means you should not hire. It means the arithmetic has changed, and it is worth knowing that before you start the process.

 

What the outsourced alternative actually looks like

 

Outsourced call handling is not an automated menu, and it is worth saying that plainly because the two get confused. An automated menu is cheap, obvious to every caller who encounters it, and puts people off. The alternative, a trained person who answers in your business name, learns how you operate, and handles calls the way you would want them handled, is a different proposition entirely.

 

At Need More Time, calls are handled by UK-based trained administrators working under your business name. No scripts. No call centre. A real person who has taken the time to learn your business, your tone, your common enquiries, and what you want done with each type of call. Messages taken and sent through, or calls patched through live, depending on what you have asked for.

 

The service runs Monday to Friday, eight in the morning until six in the evening. That covers the window when the overwhelming majority of business calls arrive, and it means you are not paying for overnight capacity you would never use.

 

For the Business Assistant service, which goes well beyond call answering into sales support, customer management and complex administration, the same principle applies. You are not taking on a hire, not managing annual leave or sick cover, and not sitting across the table from an employment tribunal six months down the line because a three-month hire did not work out.

 

Flexibility when someone is off

 

This is where the comparison between the two options is sharpest, and it is the criterion that gets glossed over most often in these discussions.

 

Your front-of-house employee takes two weeks off in August. Or goes off sick on a Monday morning when you have a day of client calls coming in. Or is simply having one of those days where nothing is going right and the phone gets answered in a way that does not reflect well on the business. All of that is the reality of having one person covering one role.

 

With outsourced call handling, the person who answers your phone is part of a wider team. Their colleague's holiday is not your problem. You do not arrange cover, you do not pay an agency for a temp, and the call does not go to voicemail whilst you are wondering what to do about it. The service continues.

 

That continuity matters in direct proportion to how much each inbound call is worth to you. For a plumbing or electrical firm where a missed call is a job that goes to a competitor, or a recruitment business where a candidate calling on a Thursday afternoon decides to go elsewhere because nobody picked up, the cost of a coverage gap is real and immediate.

 

Which option suits whom

 

Direct employment makes sense when the role is genuinely mixed, when you need someone physically present, and when the volume and consistency of work justifies a full-time hire rather than fluctuating demand for call coverage. It also makes sense if the six-month qualifying period change does not concern you because your recruitment process is rigorous and you are confident in the hire.

 

Outsourced call handling and Business Assistant support suits you if what you actually need is reliable, professional coverage of inbound calls and associated administration, without the fixed overhead of a salary, the liability of employment law, or the operational gap when someone is ill or on leave. It is particularly well-suited to businesses with between one and fifteen people, where one person off changes the shape of the whole day. The setup is fast, the cost is predictable, and there is no six-month cliff edge to worry about.

 

The Employment Rights Act has not made hiring impossible. What it has done is raise the cost of getting it wrong. For a small business owner weighing the two options, that is a perfectly good reason to think hard before the offer letter goes out.

 

If you want to talk through what call handling or Business Assistant support would look like for your business specifically, take a look at our Business Assistant service page or call us on 020 3303 3303.

 

Comments


bottom of page